Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage: Best Modern Dark Ride
Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is a dark ride at Tokyo DisneySea located in the Arabian Coast port-of-call. The attraction is a long boat ride, best described to Disney fans who haven’t experienced it as a cross between Pirates of the Caribbean and ‘it’s a small world.’ This post is mostly a “ride-through” of the attraction via photos, but I also thought I’d throw in the question of whether it is the best modern Disney dark ride, or should be considered in the same breath as the elites, at the end of the piece.
By way of background, Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage has been historically unpopular with Japanese guests—so much so that it was totally redone in 2007 and changed from Sindbad’s Seven Voyages (video at the link) to the current version of the attraction, with its tone totally shifted from dark to cheery, a new sidekick–a tiger named Chandu–added to accompany Sindbad, and a song by Alan Menken called “Compass Of Your Heart” introduced that plays throughout the journey.
I didn’t watch the video until after riding the current version of Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage at Tokyo DisneySea, so perhaps I’m a bit biased, but I think this is a prime example of re-imagining something substantially benefiting it. The substance of the ride scenes are still largely the same, but the overall package is a wholly different.
Grab your pet cat and sense of adventure, and let’s hit the high seas with Sindbad!
Attraction Overview
Describing Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage as a cross between ‘it’s a small world’ and Pirates of the Caribbean is fairly apt in just about every respect. Basically, this attraction is the story of Sindbad and his tiger, Chandu, who go out in search of adventure, foiling various foes and helping cute creatures along the way. It’s a timeless story told with a distinctly Japanese sense of kawaii. The attraction is entirely in Japanese so I don’t know precisely what’s said, but I think I more or less got the jist of what was going on without dialogue.
Queue
The queue in Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is cute, but nothing impressive in comparison to others found at Tokyo DisneySea. It’s switchbacks and brick walls with paintings of scenes from the attraction on them. Fairly basic as far as queues go. The load area is much like any other boat ride, and again contains nothing that bears mentioning.
Here are some queue photos:
Sindbad’s Send-Off
The first room in Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage after leaving load is what I’m dubbing the ‘send-off’ scene. This is set in a small village, which I presume to be Sindbad’s hometown, where everyone is present to wish him good luck on his journey. There are with belly dancers, kids playing, pantomime performances, and fortune-tellers gazing into crystal balls foretelling of the dangers that await Sindbad. And, of course, we’re introduced to Sindbad and his pet tiger (and mischievous sidekick) Chandu.
Here are some photos from this scene:
When I say everyone from the village is there, I mean everyone. In that single room, there were more Audio Animatronics than I’ve seen in any other Disney attraction built in the last decade plus. Perhaps ever–I didn’t count. All of these AAs have amazingly fluid motion, and all together they give an incredible sense of life to Sindbad’s village as the people wish him good luck on his adventures.
It was so stunning and there was so much going on that it was impossible to see it all on one ride through. Even at the end of our trip, I was noticing details that I hadn’t seen before. For me, this repeatability is one of the biggest marks of a classic Disney attraction.
Mermaid Encounter
The next room features Sindbad’s encounter with mermaids during a storm. This room does not have the same sprawling scope; instead, Sindbad and the mermaids are positioned at the end of the room with spotlights illuminating only them (sort of like the light at the end of a tunnel) as the storm happens around them. There’s not really much to the scene beyond that, but the feel of Sindbad being a beacon of light during the storm is well-established.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Roc Egg Thiefs
This scene is more elaborate in terms of both set design and Audio Animatronics. Here, Sindbad encounters thieves trying to steal Roc eggs. Sindbad successfully ties up the thieves with the help of Chandu. The mother of the Roc also assist, carrying away one of the thieves in its talons.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Treasure & Jailed Giant
In this scene, Sindbad is in a room filled with mountains of treasure. Those pesky thieves are back again, and this time Chandu alone is taking care of business. (If there’s anything I learned from this attraction, it’s that tiger cubs are tougher on crime than Smokey the Bear is on forest fires.)
Sindbad is using a beautiful feather to pick the lock that holds the Giant in a confined, little jail. In the traditional story of Sindbad, this giant is Polyphemus, from Homer’s The Odyssey. This character is more akin to the Jolly Green Giant than he is Polyphemus, but he’s best described as neither. Just a friendly, green giant.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Green Giant Concert
In the next room, Sindbad and guests learn that not only is the green giant a friendly green giant, but he has some serious musical chops. The true size of the giant is apparent in this scene, as he towers over the boats. Definitely one of (if not the) largest Audio Animatronics I’ve seen.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Sindbad’s Gift
Here, Sindbad is in another village, which contains elephants and numerous other Audio Animatronics. I’m not exactly sure what’s going on here, but I know elephants are a motif of the Sindbad stories, and one of Sindbad’s voyages often involves him receiving a special gift from one king that he is meant to take back to his king.
As Sindbad and a prominent-looking man in this seen appear to be exchanging vases of some sort, I assume that’s what this scene is, but I could be wrong. Chandu is carried on a drum by four village people.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Monkey Island
Sindbad and Chandu travel to an island of monkeys, and it appears that Sindbad becomes their king (sort of like Heart of Darkness, but with a much more upbeat vibe) as he sits in the center of them calmly beating on the drums while they wildly play music. (If there’s another thing I learned from this attraction, it’s that most animals and mythical creatures are musically-inclined.) There are also bananas literally everywhere, including in the boat where Chandu sits near the end of this room, beneath a pile of bananas.
Here are some photos from this scene:
I’m betting this scene replaced the voyage where Sindbad visits the island of crazed cannibals. Something tells me that crazed cannibals definitely would not be kawaii.
Friendly Whale Encounter
With the stench of bananas still on their breath, Sindbad and Chandu head off on the water again, where they encounter a whale, who literally lifts their boat out of the water and carries them on in the dark of night. Seeing this larger than life whale is yet another ‘wow’ moment in Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage.
Here are some photos from this scene:
Village Finale
Sindbad and Chandu return to their village with a boat full of riches, concluding their storybook voyage and cementing themselves as legends…or heroes…or whatever. In any case, the entire village is once again excited to see them, and fireworks explode overhead in celebration of their return. At the end of this room and the ride, Chandu and Sindbad bid guests farewell.
Here are some photos from this scene:
From there, you exit your boat, head outside…and if you’re like us, get right back in line! 😉
Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage Analysis
In my mind, Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is a can’t miss attraction that is exactly what Disney’s recent US dark rides should have been. (I’m looking at you, Little Mermaid dark rides!) Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage has just about everything I could want from a Disney attraction. It has a catchy song, great sets, a wait time that is shorter than the ride duration, layer upon layer of details that lend to infinite re-rideability, and characters that resonate with me emotionally.
Sindbad is the star of the show, but Chandu is the show-stealer. He’s cute, but his appeal isn’t just in that he sits there and looks cute. He displays personality throughout, and he’s helpful, mischievous, and endearing—all without any dialogue. He’s right up there for me in terms of original theme park characters, behind only the original Figment and Dreamfinder.
Chandu should be the “star” of Tokyo DisneySea, not Duffy. If Disney would take the risk and bring this expensive of an original attraction (rather than one based on Disney or licensed films) to the United States, I think Chandu would catch on in a big way here.
Most guests probably wouldn’t notice if a few of the individual Animatronics in Sindbad’s were missing, but the collective presence of all of those Animatronics creates an experience that will leave most guests muttering “wow” repeatedly as they float through the scene. You don’t get that reaction by cutting as much as you can that “might go unnoticed.”
Rooms like those in Sindbad’s like that is truly a situation where the whole is much more than a sum of the parts. I could not identify a single missing figure or two, but I can identify the feeling of wonder and awe I get when I see that whole scene alive with singing and dancing Audio Animatronics. It’s a feeling that is impossible to quantify, which may be cause for concern in Disney’s current culture where creative decisions seem to be made more and more by “numbers guys” and less by the creatives in Imagineering, but it’s the feeling you should get when experiencing a Disney attraction.
It does surprise me that Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage has not caught on more. I think this is mostly due to location. It’s tucked back in the quietest corner of the park (although they recently added a spinner, Jasmine’s Flying Carpets, to get more people back there), which could partly explain the issue. It also might be due to the original dark story of Sindbad’s Seven Voyages not appealing to guests, and perhaps the local fanbase doesn’t “buy” Sindbad’s about-face? Maybe it actually is decently popular, it just has such a high capacity that it’s never busy? All things being equal, Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage deserves at least a constant 20-minute wait.
Sindbad’s lack of popularity is inexplicable to me, and can’t be based on its quality. I consider Sindbad’s to be a flawless attraction that combines great storytelling, excellent music, and a great quantity and quality of visuals that helps the attraction resonate emotionally with guests and creates a lot of re-rideability.
Best Modern Dark Ride?
Before getting to whether Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is the best, it’s probably important to establish what’s meant by this. I don’t mean modern in the sense of technology; I’d pigeonhole those by calling them “Next Generation” dark rides. I mean modern in the sense that these rides are relatively new, and not from the first generation of dark rides built at Disneyland, or even from the generation built for the opening of EPCOT Center. Still, ‘modern’ is relatively subjective, but I’m going to make the cut-off the year 2000, which seems numerically logical, but also is the year when Pooh’s Hunny Hunt opened.
In addition to determining what’s modern, we also have to what’s a dark ride. It could be any ride in the dark, but I view this as too liberal of a definition that opens the door for including rollercoasters and other fast moving attractions (like Indiana Jones Adventure). It could also be any ride that uses a certain type of technology, but such a definition wouldn’t be evergreen. To me, a dark ride is a slow-moving indoor attraction that emphasizes scenes through which a story is told or vignettes are displayed.
By my tally, there are 5 attractions that meet this definition and are worth mentioning in competition for the title of best: Pooh’s Hunny Hunt, Monster’s Inc. Ride & Go Seek, Mystic Manor, Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle for the Sunken Treasure, and Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage. We’ve experienced all of these in person. Of these, I’d consider Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage a dark horse for the title of best. Here’s why it should be considered.
At 11+ minutes long, Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is far longer than any of the other attractions. To me, lengthy rides are more satisfying, and when I walk off a ride that is longer in duration than my wait, I feel a sense of having received great value as a guest. This isn’t a decisive factor in which is the best, but it’s worth considering.
With over 150 Audio Animatronics (per the internet), Sindbad’s has far more AAs than any of the other contenders. There’s a reason Audio Animatronics-based attractions remain popular decades after their introduction (beyond their great concepts and scripts), and that’s because they create a sense of spectacle and contain engaging scenes that more modern technology just hasn’t been able to replace.
While Audio Animatronics are conceptually old tech, each new generation of AAs is more and more technically advanced, and the AAs in Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage bear this out. No, all 150 aren’t the most highly advanced AAs Disney has ever put out, but they’re all very advanced and on whole, they push the envelope. No other modern dark ride even comes close to Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage in terms of ambitiousness with AAs.
Beyond that, it combines catchy music with good storytelling. While it’s true that not every dark ride tells a linear story, every good one uses good storytelling devices and has a catchy song. Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage continues this trend with “Compass Of Your Heart” and its beautiful storybook scenes. That I could write the scene by scene descriptions above without understanding Japanese speaks volumes to this.
While not without its faults in terms of layout and design, Sindbad’s also gets the little things right. It is awash in details, and the storybook backdrops are actually deceptively well done even if simplistic at first blush. It all comes together for an attraction that sort of sneaks up on you and surprises you on your first ride through–how could such a simple concept be so good?!
In fairness, the other dark rides listed have a far greater “wow” factor thanks to the technology they utilize. Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle for the Sunken Treasure, in particular, has some amazing visuals–but we fear it won’t age well. Mystic Manor leverages next generation tech, but in a more practical way. With those, guests experience something they haven’t experienced before, and combine that fresh experience with solid storytelling.
By contrast, Sindbad’s is amazing, but it seems like more of the same, just newer. It’s difficult to say that the other new classic dark rides are over-valued because of the technology they utilize, because their storytelling and technology are so inextricably intertwined that it’s hard to separate one from the other (the mark that technology is well-used in an attraction).
It’s really difficult to peg the “best” anything, as that’s an entirely subjective term. Ultimately, while I think Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage is properly mentioned in the same breath as Pooh’s Hunny Hunt, Monster’s Inc Ride & Go Seek, and Mystic Manor, and Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle for the Sunken Treasure, I can’t say that it’s objectively better than any of them.
While those push the envelope and hit all the right notes with regard to the fundamentals of what a dark ride should be (excepting, perhaps, duration), Sindbad’s is mostly an updated version of a classic dark ride that nails the fundamentals. This is not to downplay or diminish Sindbad’s. It’s a new classic in its own right.
What I can say is that I enjoy Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage more than the other attractions listed here, and I think it has more whimsy, emotional resonance, and other intangibles that are impossible to articulate, but typify the Disney dark ride experience. Your mileage may vary, but to me, Sindbad’s Storybook Voyager is the best of the bunch.
If you’re thinking of visiting Japan for the first time and are overwhelmed with planning, definitely check out our Tokyo Disney Resort Planning Guide. It covers much more than the parks, from getting there to WiFi to currency and much, much more. For more photos and an idea of what we did day-by-day during our first visit, read our Tokyo Disney Resort Trip Report.
Your Thoughts…
Regardless of whether you’ve had the chance to experience Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage, what do you think of it? Does it sound and look like an attraction you’d enjoy? Do you think it continues Disney’s heritage of great and detailed dark rides? Hearing from readers is half the fun, so share your take in the comments!
I think the middle scene is a visit to Mughal India, based on what looks like the Taj Mahal in the background.
Having rode on all of them except Mystic Manor, I’d give Sinbad tops because it doesn’t rely on technology for its appeal, but rather quality and detail. If you removed the trackless technology from Hunny Hunt and flashlights from Monsters, the rides themselves wouldn’t come close to the quality of Sinbad.
Glad to see the old journalism rule of thumb is intact. “If a headline ends in a question mark, the answer is ‘No.'” 😉
LOL @ the implication that this blog qualifies as “journalism.” 😉
Thanks for the amazing tribute to this attraction, Tom. I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment of Sinbad as being in the running for best modern dark ride (and even best overall dark ride) at any Disney park. Having just returned from spending 4 days in Tokyo Disney (our first trip to an international Disney park) we were fully wowed by the whole experience: the quality of maintenance throughout the parks, the immersive theming and detailing, and many (most) of the attractions themselves — Center of the Earth, 20,000 Leagues, Hunny Hunt, Tower of Terror all gave us a complete wow factor. But for me, now a few days removed from the trip, the one attraction that has resonated with me the most is Sinbad. We probably rode it 6 or 7 times due to the short line and our instant love of the experience, and more than anything else in the two parks, this attraction gave me that hard-to-describe emotional connection that is paramount to everything I love about Disney parks. I am still singing the song; I can still picture in great detail dozens upon dozens of the vivid characters on the journey, down to the expressions on their faces; I can still *feel* the joy of sitting on that boat and gently cruising though these varied and enchanting scenes. I will return to Tokyo Disney for MANY reasons, but riding this again is first on the list.
A few technical notes on elements of the ride that are likely recent upgrades since your outstanding ride-through summary (or maybe they are small details you didn’t mention):
1. In the mermaid scene, they have added actual rain. Nothing that will get you soaked, or even wet really. But an actual light rain for the first 4 or 5 seconds as you enter the storm/mermaid room. The first half of the room (on the left side) also features projection effects of a blowing rainstorm.
2. In the Monkey Island scene, they have added a really fun banana scent (think banana Runts), which might make it onto the next edition of your Top 10 Smells List, International Edition. It is piped into the whole room at just the right level.
3. In the Jailed Giant scene, they’ve added nice fiber-optic glowing details on Sinbad’s feather “key”, just adding a little life and newer technology, which strengthens the feeling that the feather is somehow magical.
While none of these things are game changers on their own, they nevertheless add to the overall immersive magnificence of the Sinbad attraction. Particularly #’s 1 and 2 are not elements you see on run-of-the-mill dark rides, and add factors of uniqueness and technology that bump Sinbad’s Storybook Voyage even more into contention for the Best Dark Ride mantle.
Thanks again for this article. It has put into words the many feelings I had about this phenomenal attraction. It alone is reason enough for any true Disney-parks fan to make the trek to Tokyo. Here’s hoping Disney bring this (or something similar) to the US parks soon. It would be perfect tucked in the back of Morocco at EPCOT, added to Adventureland at MK, or even incorporated into Animal Kingdom.
We just returned from visiting the Tokyo Disney Resort, and I absolutely LOVED this attraction!!!! We had to buy Chandu of course, and I completely agree that this attraction and character should be the star and mascot of Tokyo Disney Sea, there’s not much of a story and there’s no ride for Duffy. I like Duffy too, he is cute….but Chandu I fell in love with, along with this ride and the song “Compass of Your Heart.” Even sung in Japanese, (being a native English speaker I didn’t understand a word), I loved the tune, it was very catchy. I wish they’d bring an attraction like this, if not this exact one, especially with Chandu, here in the U.S.; it would be an incredible addition to any park. I would buy all Chandu merchandise, he’s SOOOOO ADORABLE!!!!! To me Chandu and Sindbad’s Storybook Voyage represent the best Tokyo Disney Sea has to offer……best mascot, best characters, best story, best song!!! Thanks 🙂
We wandered into this ride last Dec to escape the cold, and went on it about 5-6 times that same
night. We love the music, the story and the AAs…so epic! We just came back from TDS, and my favorite souvenir from this trip is the flyer with the English translation of the ride. Bought a little stuffed Chandhu toy as a memento, wish TDS would make more Sindbad memorabilia.
Would have to disagree with you about turning Chandhu into the “park mascot”, Duffy is definitely cuter. The Oasis cafe sells “Chandhu’s tail”, a chicken sausages with griddle marks to look like tiger stripes. A bit morbid if you ask me, hah!
My family just went on this ride this past week (May 2015). When we got on, one of the staff handed us a piece of paper with the Sinbad story in English, with the lyrics for each room so we could understand what was going on. Pretty cool. 🙂
I acme across this ride via an article of rides that have chnaged in the amusment parks. The original was really a one time thing, but this version just blew me away. I agree that this and Mystic Manor may have a place in orlando as in an Adventure Land even in animal kingdom as that the Yeti in Everest is not always functioning. The Little mermaid ride looked like it was done by someone who has no clue that animatronic were invented.
Oh man, I went on this ride to solely rest my feet and nap. I went on either 2 or 3 times (can’t remember) and there were no lines at all. I admit, that damn song was stuck in my head for a couple of days after.
I totally agree with you! The Sindbad ride(I spell it like that since I’m a native Japanese speaker) is great storytelling wise, music, and visual effects. I just went to Japan for my annual trips to relatives; last year, I went to TDL, but wasn’t wowed by it. I went to Disney Sea this year for the first time in 7+ years, and I was taken back by the atmosphere alone of the park. I think this is why enjoy Tokyo Disney Sea(better than some people without a culture and language barrier)better than the parks in Anaheim. I could gush on for days about it!
I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.
I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently.
I am quite sure I will learn plenty of new stuff right
here! Best of luck for the next!
Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!
Very helpful information specially the last part :
) I care for such information a lot. I was looking for
this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and best of luck.
Here is my weblog; Andy McGlinchey
Since the admin of this web page is working, no hesitation very shortly
it will be famous, due to its feature contents.
Thanks Tom… I dont even know there was an old version until now…
I dont want to compare each version as they are both good… but I enjoy the new version than old. The old soundtrack is quite distract and doesnt really keep me revisiting…. but the new one does… Im just sad that I missed that chance to see the old version 🙁 as well as BraviSeamo
I rode this back in 2010 – it really was amazing and a pretty long ride! And just like the loveable monkey sidekick of Mystic Manor (HK), you can buy little fluffy Chandus in the gift shops! He even has the little park seal on him so you know he’s one-of-a-kind to that park! Can’t remember the price, but I do remember it being ungodly expensive.
Ha, EVERY souvenir at Tokyo Disney Resort is insanely expensive. Even worse than the US parks, I think.
I definitely agree! It really is a concert. It has a very epic feel to it. Pooh definitely has a wow factor to it, but I feel SInbad is more epic. I can’t imagine what the ride would be like without “Compass of your Heart.”
I think duration plays a big part in “epic-ness,” but “Compass of Your Heart” does have a sweeping, epic feel to it, too!
I watched the video of this ride on YouTube recently and was blown away. After seeing this and Mystic Manor, it does make me wonder why we don’t see attractions of this scale in the states very often. Sindbad feels more like a classic Disney ride in the vein of Journey to Imagination (like you mention) and World of Motion. They’re longer and have the sense of wonder, but they aren’t a gimmick that gets old after a few rides. I’m not sure if I’ll ever get to Tokyo, but I’m holding out hope!
My guess as to why we don’t see them is because Disney thinks they’re riskier and less likely to sell merchandise. A roller coaster (like Expedition Everest) is low risk no matter how it’s themed because…it’s a roller coaster. A dark ride could flop much easier if it doesn’t resonate with audiences, and it’s easier to “guarantee” a hit by incorporating characters who are popular.
I think that sort of explains why the Little Mermaid dark ride is popular despite being average, at best. If that ride replaced those recognizable characters with original IP, it would never have a line.
I’m not saying I agree with this line of thinking–I just think that’s why it occurs. Disney used to embrace risk. Now the company is calculated and fairly risk averse.
I agree with your points. They don’t seem willing to take many chances, particularly in Florida. One reason is they’re so popular and don’t need to really push it. I’m hoping that the consistent improvements to Universal will eventually push them in that direction.
I enjoyed so much Sinbad when I ride it last July. Super fun and lots of great audioanimatronics. And the music <3
I really think Sinbad and Pooh in Tokyo are the future of dark rides!
Okay now I’m REALLY looking forward to riding this one in November! Another example of a richly detailed quality attraction that doesn’t rely on video games & screens for repeatability.
I have to agree that this is a nearly perfect re-imagining of the original ride. There is something engaging about the small-scale animatronics (Small World character size) combined with extremely fluid movement, on top of highly populated vast sets that makes this ride magical. Then, on top of all that, it has one of the best theme park songs, ever. We walked around all day singing “Cowm-pawss of yurh art!”
An added bonus is that one of the themes of the ride is the richness that comes into life when you explore the wonders the world offers. If you have made the trek to Japan, you probably have the spirit of an adventurer and know the benefits exploring and understanding the world beyond your doorstep. So, on top of a first rate attraction, I find the message it imparts to be a total home run.
And, he wears cool red boots. Everyone needs cool red boots.
You hit the nail on the head with your middle paragraph. Have you ever heard the English translation? While I LOVE the Japanese version, the lyrics in the English version give me goosebumps.
Here’s Alan Menken performing it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRpns3BwA5s
The English lyrics make the theme of the ride even more poignant. Thanks for the link!
Why oh why can’t something like this come to the U.S. parks? Apparently Disney feels that we don’t “deserve” something ambitious and original. Are American audiences that spooked by something that isn’t based on existing IP? Somehow the Haunted Mansion, Pirates of the Caribbean, Space Mountain, and pretty much all of the original EPCOT Center managed to become timeless classics despite not being based on an existing property. I hope Disney finds the faith to trust that audiences can handle original attractions in the U.S. parks again.
In fairness, Expedition Everest is newer than Sindbad’s (unless you count it as being new when its tone was changed), and that’s an original attraction based on non-film IP. Of course, it’s not a dark ride, but it was a very expensive attraction that has no tie-in.
I do agree, though, that it seems the likelihood of big-budget attractions in the US without tie-ins decreases with each passing year.