Disney World Reveals Full Menu & Opening Date for New Pop-Up at Diamond Horseshoe Restaurant

Walt Disney World has announced that the new Diamond Horseshoe pop-up dining concept will open in early October 2026, only a few days after Magic Kingdom’s 55th Anniversary! Here’s the full menu of food & drinks coming to the refreshed restaurant in Liberty Square, along with our commentary and wish list for this location.

Let’s start with dates. Currently, the Diamond Horseshoe is being used for Cool Kids’ Summer at Walt Disney World, where the venue hosts Jessie’s Roundup through September 8, 2026. If you have small children and are visiting between now and then, we recommend stepping inside for a midday refresher. Jessie’s Roundup is a glorified dance party, but it’s a good one. (If you don’t have children, do not bother; there’s nothing for you here.)

Following a few week refresh, a new limited-time pop-up restaurant will debut at the Diamond Horseshoe on October 4, 2026. Advance Dining Reservations open September 29, 2026, presumably pursuant to the 60+10 rule. We anticipate the Diamond Horseshoe being popular at first, because anything new at Walt Disney World is, and potentially posing challenges even beyond then if the menu is good, as seating is limited in the restaurant. This holiday season is bound to be busy, but my expectation is that walk-up waitlist will be fairly easy by early 2027.

As for the menu at the Diamond Horseshoe pop-up, there’s a slew (more like Slue-Foot Sue, am I right?!) of new acts fresh off the skillet certain to be crowd-pleasers. Feast on shareable plates such as the delicious Sweet Golden Corn Fritters, and the hearty Queso Fundido with Barbecue Burnt Ends served with warm tortilla chips.

For travelers of all ages, whet your whistle with the Caramel Root Beer with Sweet Cream, Barq’s Root Beer with a smooth and creamy twist, and the Orange Cream Soda, Fanta Orange blended with vanilla and cream for a deliciously citrusy take on a classic. Huckleberry enthusiasts won’t want to miss the High Plains Huckleberry cocktail, and there are a number of other drinks available.

Let’s dig into the full menu for the new-look Diamond Horseshoe pop-up concept that’ll debut when the restaurant reopens on October 4, 2026…

Small Plates

Charcuterie: Cured beef, candied bacon, smoked pork, green chile cheese, smoked cheddar, and pickles
Glazed Sticky Ribs with cowboy beans and jalapeño crisps
Queso Fundido with Barbecue Burnt Ends with warm tortilla chips
Sweet Golden Corn Fritters with cilantro ranch dressing and red chili honey
Chipotle Chicken Tostada with queso fresco, lime crema, and pickled cactus salsa
Mini Hot Dog Platter: Wrapped in pastry served with tortilla chips and a side of queso

Non-Alcoholic Specialty Beverages

Orange Cream Soda: Fanta Orange with vanilla and cream
Caramel Root Beer with Sweet Cream: Barq’s Root Beer flavored with caramel, and topped with sweet cream
Enchanting Ember Lemonade: Minute Maid Premium Lemonade, strawberry, and hot honey
Enchanted Grove Lime Splash: Minute Maid Limeade, cucumber, and mint

Cocktails

Whinnyin’ Whiskey Lemonade: Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey, Aperol liqueur, strawberry purée, Minute Maid Premium Lemonade, and basil
Cactus Rose Margarita: LALO Blanco Tequila, prickly pear, lime, and agave
High Plains Huckleberry: 44° North Mountain Huckleberry Vodka, crème de cassis liqueur, lemon juice, and cranberry
Rattler Rum Punch: Bacardí Superior Rum, orange, pineapple, lime, and passion fruit, garnished with a sweet-and-spicy rim
Coal’d Fashioned: Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Mr. Black Cold Brew Coffee Liqueur, cinnamon syrup, orange bitters, and Angostura bitters

Seasonal Cocktail

In Holiday Fashion: Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, rosemary syrup, cranberry, and cinnamon

Wine Selection

Sparkling: Nino Franco Rustico Prosecco
White: Fess Parker Riesling
Red: MacMurray Estate Pinot Noir

Draft Beer Selections

Samuel Adams Boston Lager
Yuengling Traditional Lager
Cigar City Jai Alai IPA

Our Commentary

There’s nowhere to go but up.

On the one hand, there’s nothing about the pop-up menu at Diamond Horseshoe that has me excited. Some of the dishes look like they could be good, but I’d be surprised if this pop-up becomes a sleeper hit or breakout sensation on the Magic Kingdom dining scene.

On the other hand, I’m mildly reassured just by the fact that Walt Disney World took the initiative to tease and then announce this, even going so far as taking and releasing staged food photos. That evinces an effort we have not ever seen with past Diamond Horseshoe dining concepts, which were so embarrassing that Disney probably wanted them to fly under the radar. That alone is somewhat promising.

Even if this pop-up ends up being mid-tier or overly limited, there’s the very real possibility that this will be the best menu at Diamond Horseshoe in the last two decades. That’s how infamous this saloon has been over the years!

For most of our adult lives, Diamond Horseshoe has been the worst dining option at Magic Kingdom. We’ve dined repeatedly over the years, as pre-COVID, this restaurant operated seasonally and went through a variety of menus and meal services, from quick-service lunch to family-style feasts to an a la carte dinner.

Diamond Horseshoe was infamous for being a revolving door of ill-fated concepts, with each new meal managing, against all odds, to be just as bad as the one before it. Constant churning of menus is actually a red flag when it comes to Walt Disney World dining–the Italy and Mexico booths don’t do new menus for every single EPCOT festival because they’re trying to push the culinary envelope!

Post-COVID, there was actually much more consistency with the Diamond Horseshoe until this year’s Cool Kids’ Summer. For the last ~6 years, the restaurant has served a family-style feast, first as literal overflow seating for Liberty Tree Tavern, and then figuratively. Here’s my spread from the last time I dined at Diamond Horseshoe:

This was exactly the same as the “All-You-Care-to-Enjoy Bill of Fare” over at Liberty Tree Tavern. The names of the various dishes are different, but it’s otherwise identical. Not only that, but the food all comes from the exact same shared kitchen between the venues. Some diehard fans like this, but I am not one of them. As much as I have nostalgia for Liberty Tree Tavern, I find the current cuisine to be largely low-quality.

Even though it was a distinct restaurant, for all practical purposes, the Diamond Horseshoe was still just Liberty Tree Tavern overflow until Cool Kids’ Summer started and it was converted to Jessie’s Roundup. (Walt Disney World has already confirmed that the current menu will still be served at Liberty Tree Tavern.)

With the slowdown in Advance Dining Reservation demand across the board at Walt Disney World, that overflow hasn’t really been necessary for a long time. This is why, in our view, it’s a positive that Magic Kingdom is bringing a distinct dining concept to Diamond Horseshoe. Also, because two restaurants serving the same mediocre meal was a bit much.

My best guess is that Magic Kingdom is converting Diamond Horseshoe into a pop-up small plates dining concept because of the dining capacity it’s losing as a result of nearby Westward Ho and the Churro Wagon Cart closing. It’s also possible that increased foot traffic following the reopening of Big Thunder Mountain Railroad is driving this.

Magic Kingdom could definitely benefit from another restaurant added to its roster, especially at the lower end of the spectrum. One point we’ve made repeatedly is that Magic Kingdom has less quick service dining capacity in 2026 than it did pre-COVID when Tortuga Tavern, Tomorrowland Terrace, Aunt Polly’s, and Be Our Guest Restaurant all were open for lunch during peak season. I’m not 100% sure, but Magic Kingdom might have less counter service capacity than it did in the 1990s.

Given that, I welcome more being added to the culinary landscape in Magic Kingdom. I wish Tortuga Tavern were reopening as a counter service restaurant, but I’ll nevertheless happily accept a small plate concept at Diamond Horseshoe if the price is right and the speed is sufficient.

We love Walt Disney World’s recent approach to lounges, which straddle the middle ground between counter and table service. Although the menu appears much more limited, the pop-up at Diamond Horseshoe could continue that trend.

While Magic Kingdom needs more counter service capacity, Diamond Horseshoe isn’t large enough to do that at scale, and the kitchen isn’t configured for it (and cannot be, without losing Liberty Tree Tavern, too). The seating area is fairly small, probably the smallest of any restaurant in Magic Kingdom. It’s also essentially a wide open room, with very little to break up the space.

It’ll be interesting to see what Walt Disney World does with this pop-up concept at Diamond Horseshoe. In particular, I’m curious as to whether they’ll use both levels for seating or incorporate a stage show or dance party element.

Way back in the day, Diamond Horseshoe used to be a revue/jamboree much in the style of Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue at Fort Wilderness. I vaguely remember seeing it when I was a kid, but nothing has been performed on stage here since 2003.

In recent years, the only “entertainment” at the Diamond Horseshoe has been the “World Famous Self-Playing Piano.” The music is nice, but it’s a shadow of what once was. Obviously, the time for mourning the loss of the revue or jamboree entertainment at the Diamond Horseshoe has long passed.

However, I do think it’s fair to point out that this venue was built for that purpose, and has essentially been a flex space for years. There’s a lot of unused a/v equipment, the bars aren’t used for any practical purposes, and the upstairs seating is unavailable. The presentation of the space has been sloppy and not to Disney’s standards.

If the pop-up dining concept coming to Diamond Horseshoe addresses these criticisms, it’ll be an improvement over the previous version of this restaurant, when it was de facto overflow seating for Liberty Tree Tavern.

As I shared previously, my one ‘wish list’ item for the menu at the Diamond Horseshoe pop-up is that it serves the Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake from the family-style menu. This is one of the best desserts in all of Walt Disney World. It doesn’t rank as the definitive #1 for me, but it’s incredibly close. Always in the top 10, which is incredibly high praise for a dessert at an all-you-can-eat meal.

The base has the density and flavor of a thick toffee-chocolate chunk cookie, with a crunchy exterior giving way to a gooey center. It’s topped with plain vanilla ice cream, caramel, chocolate sauce, and toffee chips. Much like the rest of the meal, the ingredients here are all a bit ordinary on their own. Unlike those, this somehow comes together in perfect harmony, with the end result being one of the most addictively good, rich and delicious desserts you’ll have anywhere at Walt Disney World.

Given the shared kitchen, it would be very easy to serve this at Diamond Horseshoe, much in the same way you can order the bread pudding from ‘Ohana at Tambu Lounge or from Sebastian’s Bistro at Banana Cabana. Those off-menu offerings are the reason to do both of those lounges, so here’s hoping that Walt Disney World keeps that trend going with Diamond Horseshoe and the Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake!

Here’s also hoping this pop-up dining concept at Diamond Horseshoe is the start of something bigger. Maybe this is the first piece of the puzzle, with Tortuga Tavern also reopening or counter service lunch being restored at Be Our Guest Restaurant.

Perhaps Walt Disney World is bringing Diamond Horseshoe online because it has plans to take Pecos Bill offline, which has been rumored for years. That seems inevitable at some point, especially with the Piston Peak Cars Land only a few years away from opening and not featuring a full-scale counter service restaurant of its own.

Regardless of the reason, it’s good to see Walt Disney World switching things up with Diamond Horseshoe. And we say that as fans with long memories of the revolving door of awful attempts at revitalizing Diamond Horseshoe back in the aughts. Whatever the outcome here, it’s gotta be better than the worst of those ill-fated efforts!

Planning a Walt Disney World trip? Learn about hotels on our Walt Disney World Hotels Reviews page. For where to eat, read our Walt Disney World Restaurant Reviews. To save money on tickets or determine which type to buy, read our Tips for Saving Money on Walt Disney World Tickets post. Our What to Pack for Disney Trips post takes a unique look at clever items to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Ride Guides will help. For comprehensive advice, the best place to start is our Walt Disney World Trip Planning Guide for everything you need to know!

YOUR THOUGHTS

What do you think of the menu at Diamond Horseshoe? Excited to try the small plates pop-up dining concept when it debuts on October 4, 2026? Hope that glorious Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake makes the small plates menu? Do you agree or disagree with our thoughts? Any questions we can help you answer? Hearing your feedback–even when you disagree with us–is both interesting to us and helpful to other readers, so please share your thoughts below in the comments!