It’s a Christmas Miracle! Disney World’s Viral Dessert Gets Even Better with New Holiday Edition

I’m dubious of anything at Walt Disney World that goes viral. Lot of folks on social media don’t have great taste, just need content to feed the beast, jump on the bandwagon, offer arbitrarily contrarian takes for the sake of edginess, dismiss the mainstream popular thing as overrated, have no sense of value, don’t appreciate actual quality, etc. The list goes on and on, unfortunately.

Admittedly, though, sometimes they get it right! Enter the newest viral dessert at Walt Disney World, which debuted earlier this year at Terra Treats in Animal Kingdom. This new viral dessert arrived at the Terra Treats snack stand around the extinction of Dinoland USA as a substitute for the fan-favorite handmade ice cream sandwiches.

The new sweet treat in question is the Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich, which is a brownie layered with vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate chips and edible cookie dough. There’s a new twist on this glorious dessert for Christmas, and I’m happy to report that it’s somehow, against all odds, better than the original…

Before we dig into the new dish, we want to distinguish between it and the existing “new” option that’s now available. Walt Disney World has made this unnecessarily confusing for Christmas, and some guests are going to accidentally order the wrong when when attempting to try the new dessert.

The Christmas edition is NOT located at Terra Treats. This is despite that location having a “new” version of the snack available from now through January 3, 2027 for the holidays. That one is listed as the “new” Festive Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich: Cookie dough with holiday sprinkles layered with vanilla ice cream and fudgy brownie.

Can you spot the difference between that and the original? Spoiler: it’s sprinkles. That’s it. Now, perhaps I’m just not a connoisseur of sprinkles, but I cannot discern a difference in taste between normal sprinkles and holiday sprinkles that are red and green. But perhaps more research is necessary. For context, here is the original Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich:

The actual new Christmas 2026 version is sold at Santa’s Holiday Grove near Theater in the Wild, and available from November 13, 2026 through January 3, 2027. Meaning it’s not out for another couple days, but we had the chance to taste-test the various Santa’s Holiday Grove offerings as part of a media event.

Santa’s Holiday Grove is the new-for-Christmas 2026 addition at Animal Kingdom, which is an indirect replacement for the Annual Dino Institute Holiday Party on the back porch of the now-defunct Restaurantosaurus. Santa’s Holiday Grove will feature a trail with intermittent snow flurries and Santa himself, ready to hear your holiday wish list.

This walkthrough will utilize the former Rivers of Light seating area, plus a portion of the back towards Discovery Island, and the side entrance to Tropical Americas. Here’s the new version of the iconic Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich that’ll be served back here:

Here’s the full menu for the food booth in Santa’s Holiday Grove:

• Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich (New): Double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough layered with vanilla ice cream and fudgy brownie
• Pistachio Cookie (New): White chocolate chip cookie with Sicilian pistachios, dried cranberries, and candied orange
• Pan de Jamon (New): Smoked ham, olive, and orange raisin bread roll
• Chocolate Tree Croissant (New): Croissant filled with hazelnut spread dipped in white chocolate
• Santa Hat Croissant (New): Croissant filled with hazelnut spread dipped in white chocolate
• Jalapeño-Cheddar Pretzel (New)
• Cookie Butter Milkshake (New): Topped with whipped cream, caramel, and a chocolate-dipped cookie
• Chilled Mulled Wine (New): Chilled Cabernet Sauvignon mulled with fresh orange, star anise, cinnamon, and cloves
• Festive Chocolate Chip Cookie (New): Chocolate chip cookie with holiday sprinkles
• Mixed Berry Focaccia (New): Blackberry, blueberry, and raspberry compote focaccia with lemon icing
• Chocolate-dipped Mickey Gingerbread: Mickey gingerbread cookie dipped in chocolate

While we had the chance to taste-test many of these new dishes, our focus here is on the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich, which actually is new. And not just thanks to some sprinkles–this is a fresh twist on the viral dessert that everyone loves.

The material change here is that the standard cookie dough has been swapped out for double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough. This makes a big difference, both in the flavor of the dessert and its decadence.

I can easily polish off a Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich by myself. I probably shouldn’t, but I can. Sharing is not something I do or recommend with the regular edition. However, eating the entire Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich by myself proved to be a challenge.

I got 80% of the way through it because it was so addictively delicious, but I probably should’ve stopped around halfway. And with several other delicious dishes at Santa’s Holiday Grove, sharing this probably isn’t the worst idea, anyway.

As far as flavor goes, the double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough is both distinctly chocolatey and peppermint.

It’s rich and indulgent, but at the same time, it does not taste like toothpaste. The peppermint is not overpowering, but it’s sufficiently present to make this a very Christmasy dessert. With that said, I am someone who is a big fan of all things peppermint, and one of my biggest perpetual complaints about Walt Disney World’s culinary lineup for Christmas is that there isn’t enough peppermint.

In this case, the double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough is further aided by (unadvertised) candy cane pieces on the top of the sandwich. There aren’t a ton of them but there are enough for both flavor, and a crunchy texture that isn’t present in the OG Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich. My biggest quibble with this is actually that there aren’t more candy cane pieces; I think they actually add a lot in both regards.

Beyond that, the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich has all of the same strengths of the regular edition. Also like that, it fully delivers on the hype.

For those who are unfamiliar with it, this is basically an open-faced ice cream sandwich, for lack of a better description. It comes wrapped in a nondescript brown paper, maybe themed to India or whatever. Although that makes for a less photogenic dish, it’s an asset here as you don’t really want to touch any part of this dessert itself.

It’s about the size of a standard stack of one-hundred dollar bills. Because who among us isn’t carrying big stacks of cash at Walt Disney World for dessert measuring purposes? (Assuming it’s arrival day as opposed to departure day.)

The dessert combines three layers. A brownie base and vanilla ice cream center, just as you’d expect from a more conventional ice cream sandwich. The twist is that the top layer is double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough.

Finishing off the Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich are mini chocolate chips and sea salt, plus candy cane pieces. I know it’s not to everyone’s tastes (so take this with a grain of salt), but I’m a fan of salt finishing. It enhances sweets, giving them a mouthwatering quality.

Everything else works incredibly well together, too. You can’t go wrong with brownie or classic vanilla ice cream, and who doesn’t love cookie dough (especially the double-chocolate peppermint variety). Each of these layers also adds a bit of variety, texture-wise, to make for a satisfying dessert.

I’m not going to pretend the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich is the pinnacle of the culinary arts. We need not dissect the flavor profile and its nuances. There’s no subtlety to this.

It’s a big ole hunk of dessert, dense and delicious. It’s like Frankenstein’s dessert. The kind of distinctly American (and by extension, patriotic) dish that would make Sam Eagle proud. It actually reminds me of something that Trader Joe’s would come up with, and that would sell out on day one and then have people stalking the restocks and somehow selling it on eBay for hundreds of dollars.

That’s the ballpark we’re in with the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich. This is a rich, decadent and indulgent dessert. If you like double-chocolate peppermint cookie dough, brownie, and vanilla ice cream…and think the results when combining the three might be yummy, this is for you. If not, it’s not.

The Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich will make our list of the Best-Value Uses of Disney Dining Plan Credits at Walt Disney World the next time that gets an update. There should actually be a few different desserts in Santa’s Holiday Grove that are good values on the DDP; anything above $7 is a smart use of a credit.

When ordering the OG Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich from Terra Treats, we recommend enjoying it near the cotton-top tamarin triplets at the ‘entrance’ to the Discovery Island Trails. This quiet trail is also a ‘shortcut’ between Terra Treats and Eight Spoon Cafe, making it easy to visit both snack stands for a perfect savory and sweet one-two punch.

The counterparts to the OG sandwich are my beloved Buffalo Chicken Chips and the Baked Mac & Cheese, if you’re looking for quick-hit recommendations. Animal Kingdom is home to an embarrassment of culinary riches, despite being the park where Walt Disney World guests spend, on average, the least time.

When it comes to the new Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich, we’ll likewise make a few pairing picks from the savory side of the menu at Santa’s Holiday Grove.

Of the dishes that I had the chance to try during the media event, my favorite savory pick was the Pan de Jamon: Smoked ham, olive, and orange raisin bread roll. I enjoyed the medley of flavors here, and the smoked ham and olives worked surprisingly well with the hint of orange in the bread roll. It is definitely olive-forward, though, so it’s not for those in your party who dislike olives.

This was touted as a teaser for Tropical Americas, albeit not one of the dishes that’ll necessarily be served there. Animal Kingdom has rolled out several dishes this year that hint at menus for the expansion, and are presumably tests to see where guests tastes are.

Another excellent option is the Mixed Berry Focaccia (above): Blackberry, blueberry, and raspberry compote focaccia with lemon icing. I’d describe this focaccia as “savory-adjacent.” It’s a good middle of the road option that tastes delicious, and is not cloyingly sweet. It’s also huge, making it a great shareable option.

A final top pick for me is the Pistachio Cookie (below): White chocolate chip cookie with Sicilian pistachios, dried cranberries, and candied orange. This is more straightforward, but nevertheless delicious. It’s one of the better cookies at Walt Disney World during the holiday season, which is fairly high praise as EPCOT has a strong cookie game.

The only thing that catches my curiosity that I didn’t have a chance to try is the Jalapeño-Cheddar Pretzel. Walt Disney World has done this elsewhere in the past, and it’s been fantastic. It strikes me as another option that’ll pair well with the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich.

With at least three other must-order snacks and desserts at Santa’s Holiday Grove, it makes sharing the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich a little easier. Even so, if you encounter a long line and are on the fence about sharing or not sharing, maybe just get your own.

I’m already planning a return “research” trip to Animal Kingdom to try the full menu, craving the ice cream sandwich and trying to justify ordering a full one for myself. Maybe I’ll do the savory dishes earlier in the morning and then the sandwich late afternoon.

Speaking of which, we’re expecting long lines for the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich. At least, initially. When the OG version debuted, there were ~30 minute long lines even shortly after rope drop.

In the months since, I’ve found more manageable ~5 to 10 minute waits. There have even been times when I’ve spotted no wait whatsoever. Part of that, though, is undoubtedly aided by a dedicated line just for the Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich to the left of the snack stand that has been set up more recently to address crowds.

It’s our understanding that everything is going to be served from a single snack stand at Santa’s Holiday Grove. I kind of expected a few different chalets, but apparently that won’t be the case. It remains to be seen whether there’s a separate cashless cart for the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich. Here’s hoping that there is, as DAK was surprisingly busy on the recent days I’ve visited in November.

Back when we first reviewed the OG sandwich, we shared a video of the Walt Disney World Ambassadors with the pastry chefs responsible for the culinary creation. They described tasting the dessert for the first as their “Ratatouille” moment with the dessert, likening it to the Pixar film’s famous food memory scene. “It’s a really huge feat for us, to evoke that childhood nostalgic memory,” explained the chefs.

They nailed both the creation of the dessert itself and describing its appeal. As we’ve written repeatedly, so much of Walt Disney World’s appeal for repeat guests is nostalgia and sentimentality for the seemingly little things around which we’ve formed core family memories. Nothing is as effective as making guests feel like children again.

Whether that be biting into this dessert and taking them back to simpler times, or the joys and thrills of rides, transportive themed environments, disbelief-suspending attractions–the list goes on and on. In the case of the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich, it’s like revisiting fond memories of holidays with family and friends.

Honestly, that’s probably why I love peppermint desserts and all things Christmas. There’s just so much baked-in nostalgia. That’s doubly true with the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich, which is a double dose of sentimentality for Christmas and Walt Disney World, on top of its double-chocolate and peppermint goodness.

That’s how this dessert, against all odds, manages to not just live up to the hype of the original, but exceed it. Do not miss the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich during your Christmas trip to Walt Disney World! Now let’s have a version of the dessert with pumpkin ice cream for Halloween 2027!

Planning a Walt Disney World trip? Learn about hotels on our Walt Disney World Hotels Reviews page. For where to eat, read our Walt Disney World Restaurant Reviews. To save money on tickets or determine which type to buy, read our Tips for Saving Money on Walt Disney World Tickets post. Our What to Pack for Disney Trips post takes a unique look at clever items to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Ride Guides will help. For comprehensive advice, the best place to start is our Walt Disney World Trip Planning Guide for everything you need to know!

YOUR THOUGHTS

Have you tried the OG Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich? Think it lives up to the hype or not? Looking forward to trying the Peppermint-Chocolate Cookie Dough Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich during Christmas 2026 at Walt Disney World? What about the other Santa’s Holiday Grove snacks at Animal Kingdom? Any questions we can help you answer? Hearing your feedback–even when you disagree with us–is both interesting to us and helpful to other readers, so please share your thoughts below in the comments!