Disney’s Yacht Club vs. Beach Club Resort
Disney’s Yacht & Beach Club Resorts are sister hotels located across Crescent Lake from the BoardWalk at Walt Disney World, both within walking distance of EPCOT and Hollywood Studios. This head-to-head comparison weighs pros & cons of each, picking a “winner” in theme, atmosphere, rooms, dining, transportation, location and more.
This continues our Walt Disney World Hotel Comparison Series, which includes several other difficult dilemmas you might face when trying to pick a hotel. Other versus posts include Animal Kingdom Lodge vs. Wilderness Lodge, Port Orleans Riverside vs. French Quarter, Caribbean Beach vs. the Poly, etc.
Most notable from the perspective of this post: Beach Club vs. BoardWalk Inn and Beach Club vs. Swan & Dolphin. Although those focus on Beach Club, this trio of posts should collectively help you determine which Crescent Lake Resort is for you. Figure out which hotel wins here, and then move on to the BoardWalk and Swolphin H2Hs, whether either of the ‘clubs’ are fairly interchangeable for the purposes of those comparisons.
The reason we’re comparing the Yacht & Beach Club despite them being so similar is to provide a bit more insight into the upsides and downsides of each. Honestly, our Rankings of ALL Walt Disney World Hotels from Worst to Best don’t do full justice to Yacht Club. We took the easy route there, ranking it lower than we might otherwise because Beach Club is the better option for first-timers.
In reality, Yacht and Beach Club are sister resorts that are physically connected to one another, but this does not mean they should be viewed as a pair. Debunking this “myth” of sorts is basically our main motivation for writing this comparison. In fairness, their interchangeably does apply in some regards, such as transportation, dining, and amenities; in terms of theme, rooms, and in other regards, they are stark contrasts.
When you stay in a Walt Disney World resort hotel, you’re paying a significant premium over a real world venue, and that’s largely for a few things: location, rooms, and themed design. Given that, we think choosing a resort with atmosphere that appeals to you is incredibly important.
Setting aside the general ‘nautical-ness’ of each resort, the theme and ambiance of Yacht Club and Beach Club and significant departures from one another. If anything, Beach Club is more comparable to BoardWalk Inn from an atmospheric perspective, whereas Yacht Club is (arguably) more like a nautical Grand Floridian. Or perhaps closer to the Four Seasons or some other real-world luxury hotel.
Suffice to say, the resort theme (and by extension, the room theme) should be a significant deciding factor in this showdown. As such, the first two variables in this Walt Disney World hotel comparisons. Unlike our other entries into this series, we do not use all six elements of two different resorts to determine which is “the best.” In fact, this comparison seeks less to crown a definitive champion and more to compare and contrast.
Theme/Atmosphere: It Depends
While technically sister resorts, the theme and tone of each resort is dramatically different. Beach Club has a theme resulting from former Disney CEO Michael Eisner’s obsession with his childhood vacations in the seaside communities of the Northeast. Its theme is meant to evoke the seaside resort cottages scattered around New England in the early 20th Century.
Beach Club is very laid back; both in the substance of the theme, and the styles used. There are a lot of light colors and pastels, and this makes for a relaxing environment. The only thing slightly at-odds with this is that the lobby is sometimes noisy and chaotic, more so than the Yacht Club lobby. All things considered, though, I’d say Beach Club shares more with BoardWalk Inn in terms of theme and atmosphere than it does with Yacht Club.
By contrast, Yacht Club feels like an actual high-society yachting club set in turn of the century New England. If I were to describe it in a single word, I’d call it “stately.” The color scheme is much more muted and darker, and there’s also an abundance of deep woods, nautically-themed antiques, and rich furniture throughout the resort. The environment could pass for a place where the Kennedys and other elites might have met for liquid lunches and made power plays.
This environment can be off-putting for some families. The one word we hear most frequently when it comes to criticism of Yacht Club is “stuffy.” While we think it stops well short of being stuffy or unfriendly to families, it’s definitely more sophisticated and less laid back.
While the detractors view Yacht Club as stuffy, the argument could just as easily be made that it’s more sophisticated and refined. That instead of the light and breezy atmosphere of Beach Club, you’re getting something more mature, like a real world luxury hotel–and a look that’s commensurate with the cost. We’ve spent a lot of time in coastal California, and many of the finest oceanfront hotels there are similar in vibe to Yacht Club.
Our take is that both of these resorts offer exceptional attention to detail and do an incredible job of conveying their respective themes, and setting a tone for the resort via those themes. Which is “better” will largely be a matter of personal preference–whether you prefer refined or laid back. Either one can have nice vacation vibes that offer a nice contrast to the chaos of the parks; it all depends on what you find calming.
Rooms: Yacht Club
This is much easier. Both resorts recently completed room refurbishments, replacing some fairly dated rooms for more modern ones. The end result at Yacht Club is dramatically superior. The room more well-appointed, with on-theme design elements, pops of color, and plenty of Disney details, addressing previous criticism. See Review: Refined Redone Rooms at Walt Disney World’s Most Sophisticated Resort.
Beach Club’s new rooms are nice, but bland. The recent room refurbishment there removed the carpet and added Donald Duck artwork, but didn’t go far enough in addressing guest concerns. Better than they were before, but they still remind us of slightly Disneyfied mid-grade chain hotel rooms you could find pretty much anywhere, except with a light beach motif.
They are not necessarily bad, but feel uninspired to us, and among the weakest of the redone rooms. Not quite what we expect given the price points of Beach Club. (The Beach Club Villa rooms are better, but this is not a DVC comparison.)
With that said, both sets of rooms are very much an extension of the style of their resorts. If you find the lobby of Yacht Club ‘stuffy and drab’ you’ll feel the same way about the guest rooms. If you enjoy the ‘light and airy’ nature of Beach Club, you’ll find that extended into the guest rooms.
Transportation/Location: Push
This is a really poor basis for choosing between the two, but Beach Club is slightly closer to the International Gateway entrance of EPCOT. This also makes it closer to the Skyliner station, which offers access to several hotels plus Disney’s Hollywood Studios.
On the other hand, Yacht Club is closer to Disney’s Hollywood Studios. Although fewer guests walk to DHS than EPCOT, this is the optimal approach for reliably getting to the park fastest. (We’ve “raced” and feet perform better over time than the boats; Skyliner almost never wins.)
However, we’re talking a few minute difference for both EPCOT and Disney’s Hollywood Studios, at most. It also depends on where your room is located, as both hotels have interminably hallways that can exceed the distance to the park. Slight exaggeration, but sometimes it feels that way.
In terms of boat transportation, the two are equal as they share a boat dock. They’re also equal for bus transportation, with shared buses. We do not recommend anyone choose between Beach Club and Yacht Club on the basis of location. The difference nets out to almost nothing at all unless you’re doing EPCOT or DHS more than the other.
Amenities: Push
This is largely about dining and pools, which are usually separate categories. Since all pools and restaurants are shared between these two sister properties, there is no meaningful distinction between any of these.
With that said, it’s always worth noting that Stormalong Bay is awesome, and is a good basis for choosing either (or both!) of these resorts. Stormalong Bay is the gold standard of Walt Disney World pools. This sprawling pool complex 3 acres in size with sand at the bottom, a lazy river, pleasant lounging space, and 230-foot water slide is in a league of its own. This is one of the best amenities in all of Walt Disney World.
Conversely, all Crescent Lake resorts (not just Y&BC, but also BoardWalk and Swolphin) have pathetic counter service choices. Additionally, all of the restaurants throughout Crescent Lake are so incredibly easy to access from one another that we don’t think dining is an outcome-determinative factor for any of these hotels.
Cost: Push
Standard room rates are identical (well, sometimes there’s like a $10 difference–but it cuts both ways), with higher tiers seeing some differences.
The outcome determinative factor here is discounts, and those are variable. Yacht Club is one of Walt Disney World’s major convention hotels, and when it’s hosting an event, special offers are scarce. Conversely, it tends to be slightly less popular than Beach Club at other times, and we’ve found both easier availability and better discounts. But this is very much YMMV.
Although beyond the scope of this comparison, it is worth noting that Beach Club has a Disney Vacation Club wing whereas Yacht Club does not. If you’re renting DVC points to save money, the only viable option here is the Beach Club Villas.
Verdict: It Depends
It’s impossible to crown a winner from an objective perspective. In our experience, first-timers and infrequent visitors have historically preferred Beach Club. But not everyone does, and the basis for that almost entirely boils down to atmosphere–more people preferring the light and airy ambiance of Beach Club than the stately and sophisticated style of Yacht Club. All of this is purely subjective, obviously. We cannot say one executes its theme better than the other.
From an objective perspective, the problem is twofold. First, these resorts share so many amenities that it’s downright impossible to crown one victorious without splicing them down the middle and only counting those locations physically within each resort. That’s a nonsensical approach given the shared grounds, and the fact that some rooms in Yacht Club may be farther from that resort’s amenities than some Beach Club rooms (and vice-a-versa).
Really, the single element of the two resorts where there’s a decisive advantage is in terms of room quality, where Yacht Club prevails. However, even there, we’ve encountered a lot of people who prefer the new rooms at Beach Club because of their vibe and atmosphere. So once again, even that will largely be decided by subjectivity.
One of the reasons we’ve revisited this topic is because the gap has closed in Walt Disney World fan perceptions of Yacht & Beach Club. When we first did this comparison several years ago, we polled readers and Beach Club was the decisive winner–64% to 36%. We’ve redone that poll, and here’s where things currently stand:
Considering theme, atmosphere & rooms (the rest is shared), which of these two Walt Disney World hotels do you prefer:
— Disney Tourist Blog (@DisTouristBlog) December 19, 2025
Neck and neck, really reinforcing the “It Depends” verdict here. We’d note that the only major changes since we last conducted the poll are the room refreshes and slight updates to the respective lobbies.
So it would seem that this is largely a referendum on the new rooms, reinforcing what we wrote above that Walt Disney World did a nicer job with Yacht Club.
Ultimately, you really can’t go wrong either way with Yacht or Beach Club. And that’s even with the dramatically different atmospheres and rooms. We really enjoy both, and think that the sister hotels are great compliments to one another. The real difference-maker here is Stormalong Bay, which gives both the edge over many other Deluxe Resorts at Walt Disney World. Read our full Disney’s Yacht Club Review and Disney’s Beach Club Review to see more photos of each, which can help determine which will appeal more to you.
Planning a Walt Disney World trip? Learn about hotels on our Walt Disney World Hotels Reviews page. For where to eat, read our Walt Disney World Restaurant Reviews. To save money on tickets or determine which type to buy, read our Tips for Saving Money on Walt Disney World Tickets post. Our What to Pack for Disney Trips post takes a unique look at clever items to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney World Ride Guides will help. For comprehensive advice, the best place to start is our Walt Disney World Trip Planning Guide for everything you need to know!
Your Thoughts
Which resort do you prefer, Yacht Club or Beach Club? Any other considerations we didn’t take into account? Do you agree or disagree with our verdict? Any questions we can help you answer about these hotels? Hearing feedback about your experiences is both interesting to us and helpful to other readers, so please share your thoughts below in the comments!
Tom, we love these two resorts the most but I completely disagree about the location! We actually prefer the theming of yacht club but we choose the beach club location every time, and always request the wing closest to Epcot. The walk to HS may be quicker but it’s also sweaty and not particularly scenic, whereas we LOVE the skyliner and view it as a ride in itself. We also often go to or from magic kingdom via Epcot and the monorail, which means being steps away from Epcot is a huge perk. The one time we stayed in yacht club we found ourselves making sad cat noises at the beach club while walking past it almost every night.
One tip for anyone staying in the area: on the way back on the buses, get any bus going to yacht, beach, boardwalk, swolphin. They’re all easily walkable and better than waiting at a sweaty bus stop.
One potentially very niche advantage of Yacht Club… if you’re looking for a two bedroom and your budget allows it, the Turret Rooms at YC are pretty unique. I don’t think Beach Club has an equivalent.
While the Beach Club also has some Club Level 2B suites, most of them don’t have a cool name or such a nice layout. If the Turret Rooms got a similar design as the regular Yacht Club rooms did during the remodel, I’d definitely choose those over the Beach Club suites.
Any thoughts about the Regatta Room? Tom hasn’t gotten over there yet, so I’m going to need some third party opinions on how it compares to the Stone Harbor Club.
What about the pervasive seafood smell in The Beach Club lobby? I’ve read that the smell can be very strong, and I am not a seafood (or seafood smell) lover.
I was thinking as I read the article that there is no mention of the seafood smell of the lobby at Beach Club. I have not stayed at Beach Club but have gone there for dinner. I found the fishy smell from Cape May to be enough for me to choose not to stay there. We have stayed at Yacht and loved it. Another factor in why we prefer Yacht over Beach is that all the rooms at Yacht have a full balcony, but not all the rooms at Beach Club have a full balcony.
Yacht club is a very nice place awesome rooms . Would recommend it
We had reservations at the Yacht Club. We arrived very early and was not allowed check in until almost 2 p.m. :-(. When we entered the room it was a train wreck! The door to the nightstand fell off, the room faced a bunch of dead trees and brush and it had wall safe with a key (ancient). We went to the front desk and asked for a better room. The manager was extremely nice and found us a water view room at the BC. It was great! The pool and restaurants are difficult to get around in/to. We always stay at the Grand and love it!
They accommodate early check ins when possible but the stated check in time is 3pm. Getting to check in an hour early is hardly something to be upset about.
Do you have any opinion or comparisons on the concierge lounges at these two resorts? I’m hoping to spend two nights at either in the near future. I’m finding it harder to find info or comparisons to the comfort, ambience, and offerings in the club lounges of these two resorts in particular.
First off, they are both excellent, so we really splitting hairs. That said, a few things to consider. Both were renovated in the last few years, but YC is newer having been completed within the last year. As mentioned in the general review, YC tends to attract a somewhat older crowd, so slighty fewer kids there. YC is also influenced a lot by conventions. If there is one at YC, the concierge level sees more activity – especially in the evening. The staff at both Clubs is excellent however YC’s is very experienced having been there a long time. Both clubs, and for that matter all of Disney’s concierge levels, have worked hard to improve the food offerings in the last year or so. I personally think the BC chef is excellent and very creative. In the end for us at least, it comes down to availability and what we have planned for that particular trip. For what it’s worth, we will be at BC Club level next week 🙂
First off, they are both excellent, so we really splitting hairs. That said, a few things to consider. Both were renovated in the last few years, but YC is newer having been completed within the last year. As mentioned in the general review, YC tends to attract a somewhat older crowd, so slightly fewer kids there. YC is also influenced a lot by conventions. If there is one at YC, the concierge level sees more activity – especially in the evening. The staff at both Clubs is excellent however YC’s is very experienced having been there a long time. Both clubs, and for that matter all of Disney’s concierge levels, have worked hard to improve the food offerings in the last year or so. I personally think the BC chef is excellent and very creative. In the end for us at least, it comes down to availability and what we have planned for that particular trip. For what it’s worth, we will be at BC Club level next week 🙂
First, I think that one point you mentioned in passing that I feel influences these resorts quite a bit is YC and the convention center and BC and DVC. My feeling ( I have stayed at both and will be at BC next week) is that this affects both the clientele and the atmosphere to a significant degree at each resort. I agree with your conclusion that with many essentially shared areas, it is a matter of taste.
Second, while in this case I think you would have another tie, I feel that evaluating the Club levels at the Deluxe resorts is an significant delineator. They are an important, and with the continued blurring of lines between hotel categories, perhaps one of the few distinguishing characteristics of the deluxes. I know your argument about expenses, but your reviews would be a lot more complete if you included the Club levels. I know it’s a tough job, but somebody has to do it.
I will probably never stay at YC because of DVC, so I’ll give BC my vote, lol.
As a couple with no kids, we always choose Yacht because it feels so much quieter and relaxed, with a serene atmosphere similar to that of the Grand without the (often excruciatingly) high price point. This offers a great reprieve from the parks while still being themed exquisitely, and there’s something to be said for a Disney resort that is geared toward adults while still maintaining a perfectly Disney vibe. The Beach is great, but I’ve never found it to be all that “beachy” – I suppose maybe it’s because when in Florida, I don’t want to feel like I’m on a New England beach; I much prefer a tropical vibe a la Old Key West. I also don’t find that the Beach’s theming “transports” the guest to another time or place quite resorts such as the Boardwalk, AKL, WL, OKW or even the Yacht, and this is key for us when choosing a Disney resort. One more point – the bus system at the Yacht for us has always been consistently better than the Beach at all times of year because the Yacht is picked up first. I can’t count how many times we have had a full bus by the time we get to the Beach and there is no room left for Beach guests. Both resorts have their place but I’d take the Yacht any day!
Good point about the busses! I’ve had that happen on other busses and am glad to know YC gets 1st pick up, which can make for a better experience. I am going next month on our first solo trip without the little ones and we’re staying at the YC for the same reasons you describe. Fingers crossed and thanks for the review. It helped ease any small concerns I had!
We just stayed almost 2 weeks at BC. One note about the bus transportation. They pick-up at the YC first. Then BC. With that said. There were many times that the Bus would show up at BC basically already full from the YC. This made it difficult to make it to reservations/fast passes on time, even when you showed up at the bus stop on time or ahead of time. If fact we didn’t want to “lose” our Be Our Guest reservation one night and had to use the Minnie Van service. (Which I might add was excellent!) We actually joked that we should catch the bus at YC.
I am older now, and opt for the serenity of the Yacht Club. (Although, even when younger, I was drawn to the Yacht Club’s subdued atmosphere more than The Beach Club). My son and daughter-in-law, however, who have six year old triplets and an eight year old, stay in a two bedroom Villa at The Beach Club, mostly because they need the room. I guess sometimes it’s more a case of need than want. Plus, they feel the location is perfect because they can hit three theme parks without taking buses.
Tom – You wrote “Yacht Club has a small number of dog-friendly rooms”. I thought I had read somewhere, perhaps on your site, when the new policy came out recently, that dog-friendly resorts could potentially have any resort room used as a dog-friendly room. However, you seem to be indicating that only specific rooms, or perhaps specific parts of a resort, have been set aside. Do you know which is actually true? This can be an issue for those who can stay in a resort that is dog-friendly but cannot necessarily stay in a room that a dog has lived in.
Separately, while we have been to the Beach and Yacht Clubs numerous times due to the wonderful Cape May buffet, we have never actually stayed there nor seen the guest rooms. We decided a long time ago that if we were to stay there, we would only stay at the Beach Club, due to a strong preference for the light pastel colours over the dark colours at the Yacht Club in the public areas.
I can’t believe you did not point out the highly localized potentially dangerous weather on Stormalong Bay outside these resorts. This is, of course, where Hurricane Hanna hit many years ago and caused that big shipwreck on the Beach Club’s beach that Disney still has not cleared away (unlike the non-imagineered Hurricane Irma which you actually encountered earlier this year). Always a handy excuse if you are late to an ADR at the two resorts.
I’m pretty sure that only a few hotels have dedicated dog friendly rooms now. So it’s not an “any room could potentially have had a dog” situation.
Yes, it is an any room could have a dog situation. Our friends stayed at POR and arequested a dog free room/bldg. They were told that would happen. When they got to POr they were put in bldg 24, which is the designated dog bldg. They were moved to the 30’s. Then they spotted a dog dong it’s business right outside their non dog bldg room. When they went to guest services and asked why? they were told “well, those guests booked online and wanted that bldg, so…… It states that any room or bldg could have dogs in them in the test resorts. And apparently the designated dog rooms/bldgs is not really true when it comes down to it.
We have booked Yacht Club for our June 2018 visit (crazy time of year, but only time we could coordinate with my cousin’s family when all our kids are out of school, etc), and I’m really looking forward to it. Based on the photos of the rooms, we like the look of Yacht Club better, and we can easily hang in the lobby & public areas of either resort if we feel like it. So we chose the nicer rooms. Decision made, as we view all else as being equal. Can’t wait to get a chance to play at Stormalong Bay! Given the weather in June, we figured a hotel with a good pool was vital! Thanks for all your great posts on this blog! Cheers.
The opening of the (really, really good) C&A Lounge must surely give a further nod to YC’s lobby. It has an incredible sense of atmosphere, and puts the “Club” in club, if you will.
Now, a more interesting comparison (although totally useless) would be to throw NPB into the mix. It really feels like a “boutique” version of YC.
I’ve stayed at BC and BCV only. I have visited YC’s lobby many times plus I have had drinks at Crew Cup Lounge. I love both resorts theming and atmosphere, my pick is BC/BCV because I prefer the dining (Cape May is one of my favorite buffets whereas Yachtsmen Steakhouse is too pricey) , closer proximity to Epcot and Boardwalk, and I love the Solarium, Drawing Room, and Breezeway areas of BCV.